We The Stars

Fandom is the star.

Being a good fan

Disagreeing Without Disrespect

Launch library · evergreen read

Photo: A massive crowd of fans are thrilled at the MTV EXIT 01 by USAID Vietnam (Public domain), via Openverse

Disagreement is a completely normal, healthy part of fandom, and handling it without disrespect simply means separating the actual argument from the person making it, engaging with what was genuinely said rather than assuming bad faith or malice on the part of whoever happens to genuinely hold a different view.

Respectful disagreement also means knowing when to simply let a particular point go, since not every difference of opinion within a fandom needs to be fully resolved or definitively won. Some disagreements are genuinely fine to leave open, quietly unsettled between two people who ultimately still like and respect each other.

Fans who consistently disagree respectfully tend to be trusted more within their community over time, since people learn they can express a differing opinion around them safely, without fear of the conversation turning unpleasant, personal or genuinely hostile purely because two honest, well meant views happened to genuinely differ.

Back to the library

Share

Sharing opens the network in a new tab. No tracking scripts are loaded on this page.

Printed from We The Stars. Sources for this article are listed at the end of the page.